Talk prepared September 2004
for as workshop at the U. of New Hampshire, Durham, NH
intended for for middle school and high school teachers.
Earlier today I was asked to tell you about the magnetosphere, about the complicated interaction involving the Earth’s magnetism, the solar wind and magnetic phenomena on the Sun’s surface, like sunspots. It is hard to teach your students about those subjects, unless both you and they have a clear understanding of the nature of magnetism. (One can also argue, that one reason for teaching about the magnetosphere is, to make the study of magnetism more interesting!)
I regret to say that even in this day and age, most of the public regards magnetism as a mystery. That has led to magnetic bracelets and similar “health products,” to magnets taped to fuel lines for better gas mileage, and to widespread worries about possible reversal of the Earth’s field, encouraged by Hollywood movies.
In the minds of most Americans magnetism is forever associated with specially treated iron, with patterns of iron filings and with the way the compass needle lines up with the north-south direction. Few schools teach much more, because, (1) physics is an elective, and (2) magnetism is covered near the end of the textbook, the school year is short, and teachers are happy if they just make it to Ohm’s law.
Some people may also know that a current-carrying wire coil wrapped around an iron bar turns it into a magnet, and about use of electromagnets in electric machinery. But it’s always with iron, or with some magnetic substance. Why sunspots would be magnetic remains completely unclear. To help you bring a little more understanding to your classes, I’ll try give here acrash course on some basic magnetic phenomena, with a few of quickclassroom demonstrations. (Slide 1)
The reason, we now know, is that the Earth, too, is magnetic. From that came the magnetic compass, quickly copied by Arab navigators and then by Europeans. We may wonder today–if lodestones did not exist, the compass might have stayed undiscovered for a long time, and wouldColumbus have ventured so far from land without it?
The Floating Compass Needle
(In place of slide 2–place a transparent compass atop a vu-graph projector)
You can demonstrate this to the class on top of a projector, using a transparent compass–the kind one can place on top of a map to orient it. I have one here with me.
However, it is much more impressive to float a small magnetized sewing needle in a Petri dish containing water, on top of that projector. It helps prevent spills if the dish has a cover, which you remove after it is safely on top of the projection glass; or else, fill it (from a cup) after placing it on the projector, to a depth of about 7-8 mm. Have a larger container to take the water afterwards, and just in case, also keep some paper towels on hand.
The needle should be the thinnest you can get–a small needle of about 3 cm is OK, heavier ones tend to sink. It should be dry, and handling it helps, as it rubs off some grease from the fingers. Magnetize it by stroking with a magnet–the button magnet used in the next demonstration can serve here.
Get several needles, just in case the first one sinks; it may be harder to float a needle again after it gets wet, although a paper towel can help dry it. .Have a small magnet on hand to magnetize the needle.
The needle won’t sink if you drop it carefully. Hold it horizontally at its middle between two fingers, just above the water, then let go. (Use fingers, not pincers: a lot of those are of iron, and the needle may stick magnetically).
(in place of slide 3–floating needle demonstration)
Of course, it then points north-south, as you can show by placing the transparent compass (used below in another demonstration) on the same projector top. Not too close, or the two magnetic needles interact. (Also, make sure the auxiliary magnet is well away, or else “north” may be in some funny direction)
But why does it float? Ah, now you can tell students about surface tension, about the thin “skin” of the top layers of water molecules, which stick together, and about water beetles which scurry over the tops of quiet ponds.
Robert Norman and an early scientific experiment
But back to magnetism, although this is mainly about explaining a very fundamental concept in science–the experiment. A scientific experiment is a way of testing nature, to learn how it behaves.
By 1580, the use and manufacture of compass needles was a well known art. The maker would take a flat steel needle, find its middle by balancing it, install a pivot there, and then magnetize it by stroking it against a magnet or a lodestone. But that was not enough. The north-pointing end always seemed heavier, and a tip had to be snipped off, to make the needle balance again.
The story goes that a compass maker named Robert Norman once snipped off too much and ruined a needle, so he devised an experiment, to find what was happening. Before magnetizing the needle, he balanced it not on a vertical pivot but on a horizontal one, lined up in the east-west direction.(Slide 4, above). Before the needle was magnetized, it stayed horizontal.Afterwards, its north end slanted down. (For some reason, the needle in Figure 4 points straight down, as it would at the magnetic pole.) Aha! The north-pointing magnetic force on the needle was not horizontal, but pointed into the Earth.
Gilbert devised an experiment which suggested a reason for the properties of the compass: the Earth itself was a giant magnet. Using as model for the Earth a lodestone fashioned into a sphere (he named it “terrella” or “little Earth”), Gilbert reproduced not only the north pointing properties of the horizontal needle, but also the downward slanting of the needle which Robert Norman made. (Slide 6)
If you dip a bar magnet into a cup of nails, nails will stick to it. But exactly, why? You know that magnets attract iron, but then you also note, some nails stick to other nails. Why that?
Gilbert guessed that the reason was that ordinary iron turned into a magnet whenever it touched another magnet. Soft iron (not steel) loses its magnetism once it is taken away, but while in contact with a magnet, he proposed, it too acts like a magnet, and its polarity is always in a direction which helps it stick to the first magnet. Thus one nail attracts another.
He proved his hunch by showing that such temporary magnets not only attracted, but could also repel. He did this by an experiment shown on the above drawing, the frontpiece of his book: the soldier on the right holds two pieces of iron suspended together from strings, just above a magnetized sphere. Their free ends here seem to repel. In actual practice this does not work too well, so we demonstrate the same effect in a somewhat different way.
Here is how you perform the experiment in class. Put a magnet on top of the projector, and allow two small nails to attach themselves to adjacent spots on one of the poles, with your fingers holding them parallel to each other.
(try holding the ends together by a small wire strand wound around them?)
Both nails are now temporary magnets with the same polarity–say, north-seeking or N–at the ends next to the magnet. The polarities of their other ends therefore must be the same–here, south-seeking or S, and those ends should repel each other. By spreading your fingers and allowing the ends of the nails to move apart, you can show that in fact they do. (Slide 7)
You might also recognize that this is a magnetic analog of theelectroscope. (Slide 8) Details of this experiment are athttp://www.phy6.org/earthmag/inducemg.htm
Your students will now understand why iron filings on a paper sheet above a magnet line up the way they do. Each little piece becomes a temporary magnet, and like a tiny compass needle, it lines up with the direction of the magnetic force.
Oersted’s Discovery of Electromagnetism
Let me quickly jump to the year 1820, not long after the invention of electric batteries. Electric currents were a hot scientific topic, but no one suspected they had anything to do with magnetism. (Slide 9–Oersted’s discovery)
A Danish professor, Hans Christian Oersted, prepared for some friends a science demonstration in his home. It included the heating of a wire by an electric current from a battery, and also some demonstrations of magnetism, using a compass on a stand.
While carrying out the heating experiment, Oersted noted that every time he connected the current, the compass needle moved, too, something completely unexpected. No one else took notice. In the four months that followed he tried hard to make sense of the phenomenon; but he couldn’t! The compass needle was neither attracted nor repelled, but tended to standperpendicular to the wire. In the end he could only report his observations in an article–written in Latin, no less.
Following Oersted’s article, the effect was confirmed all over Europe, andAndré-Marie Ampére in France figured it out, using some clever experiments. Magnetism, he claimed, was basically the force between electric currents. Parallel currents attract, anti-parallel currents repel. Loops of current attract or repel like magnets, coils with many loops multiplied the magnetic force, and Ampére guessed that iron atoms were magnetic because electric currents (soon named “Ampére currents”) circulated in them. Anelectron orbiting in an atom can carry such a current, although we know now that the actual explanation, involving electron spin, is more complicated.
(In place of Slide 10–demonstration of Oersted’s experiment)
You can perform Oersted’s experiment on top of a projector, using just a transparent compass, a D-cell and a short (say, 9″), thick, flexible insulated wire. (insulated–just in case it gets hot). The D-cell should be fresh: you will have to draw a large current from it, a short circuit really, though only for a very short time.
Put the compass on the glass, and let everyone see that it points north. Then with your thumb press one end of the wire against the bottom of the D-cell. The wire should form a short loop, coming back to the other terminal of the battery, but not touching it.
Maneuver the wire so that the middle of the wire passes over the compass needle and is parallel to it. Then touch the other end of the wire to the other end of the cell–just a short touch (1-2 seconds), it’s a short circuit and not good for the cell, also it generates a lot of heat at the contacts. The needle will immediately pivot to stand at 90 degrees to the wire.
Reverse the electrical contacts by turning the D-cell around. The needle will swing to stand at 90 degrees in the other direction.
(Details are on the web site, athttp://www.phy6.org/earthmag/oersted.htm)
Magnetization by Lightning
All you have heard here is just the bare beginning of teaching magnetism. I hope it is not too much to put in your science course–and at the same time, I hope there is enough here to arouse the interest of bright students and to make some of them, perhaps, explore magnetism on their own.